The Evolution of Motorway Signs – Part One

On 5 December, the Preston Bypass passed its 60th year in service. It started off as a humble eight-mile length of road that many would barely recognise from today, with intermittent ‘soft’ shoulders and only two lanes in each direction. A wide grassy central reservation allowed for future expansion and there was only one interchange midway along, with the A59. At both ends the motorway connected to the A6 at large roundabouts designed for future extensions of the road, eventually realised as the M6 to the south and M55 to the west (where M6 J32 now stands was a temporary bend).

However, there was one serious issue. The new road was expected to attract fast traffic, for which the existing series of traffic signs were not deemed to be satisfactory. A new way of thinking had to be developed to cater for this new way of travelling, and fast!

The 1957 TSRGD and its predecessor, the 1944 Committee on Traffic Signs, had a sign that applied for grade-separated junctions, but it was still stymied by inefficient use of the sign face and upper-case text surrounded by boxes. With the opening of the motorway occurring less than a year after the 1957 TSRGD was in force, this meant there was no time to produce a series of new signs under the existing regulatory frameworks and temporary signs had to be drafted in.

Due to this, the motorway at Preston duly received an experimental set of signs that partly inspired later designs and partly was never seen again. The long, and curious, history of the motorway sign had begun.

Practice at Preston

The Preston Bypass established some design considerations that remain with us to this day – firstly signs on the motorway itself should be blue and use a combination of the newly created Transport and Motorway typefaces. Secondly, the determination of x-heights via lower-case letters rather than the previous all upper-case was introduced and the typical motorway x-height was set at 12 inches, which today is translated as 300 millimetres. This gave the signs a massive increase in legibility at speed. Simplicity was deemed to be key.

One thing that was unique to the Preston Bypass was the motorway symbol chosen by the then Ministry of Transport. For reasons known only to them, they had taken an immediate and forceful dislike to the European conventional motorway symbol.

FrenchSymbol

The ‘elongated’ motorway symbol that the Ministry of Transport disliked. The French themselves replaced it in favour of a more British style design in 1982. Picture credit: Forum SARA.

The Ministry therefore eschewed continental practice (this seems to be a recurring theme with the UK), and developed the following abstract symbol that no-one in sign design circles has been able to explain:

27599141314_8cc99112d3_h

The abstract motorway symbol used only at Preston. This sign was situated on the slip roads from the A59 (now J31). Picture credit: Claude Ball, Flickr.

Reproductions of the 1958 “entry to motorway” signs, re-made in modern sign design software. Click to enlarge.

An interesting point regarding the design of the early signs is that they used coloured panels for the approach signs.  The Anderson Committee notably abandoned this principle; but it was re-instated as part of the 1964 TSRGD. Sometimes you have to go in circles to go forwards in British sign policy making…

27599762513_8d28fe8222_k

The former end of the A49 at Bamber Bridge, and this sign suggests the M6 starts immediately to the right if you apply today’s panel and symbol rules. The reality is there was a short length of A6 to use before joining the M6. This area has now been radically altered by the Bamber Bridge Bypass. Picture credit: Claude Ball, Flickr

Striped poles were at least still being used – this remained a TSRGD requirement until 1964. Of course, on a motorway itself that didn’t apply. Indeed, no sign supports had been considered in detail by December 1958 and it appears that a series of desperately assembled scaffolding arrangements were used before the Anderson Committee settled on the use of concrete sign supports.

image18

The temporary scaffolding supports, with a more permanent lighting installation painted in a very pleasing shade of blue. This rare colour imagery is taken from the Look at Life series. Note the lack of forward destinations – we shall return to that in a moment.

Big As Houses…

The new 12-inch x-height as mentioned earlier meant the signs on the bypass would be visible for up to half a mile away. And they were. Thanks to the wonders of the internet, photographs of most of the signs in use on the bypass now exist so we can discuss these in a bit more detail than we could ten years ago when I first wrote on this subject (alas such writing is lost to the mists of time). Much more archive material has surfaced since then.

1 mile advance direction sign

The 1 mile advance sign was simple, but had various differences from the current sign style. Firstly the ahead arm was a stub, no point provided. Secondly, the legend is shown as “1 mile” instead of “1m”. I’m not going to discuss the issues that causes given “m” is the SI unit for “metre”. Junction numbers of course did not arrive until the late 1960s. The main thing to notice is the angle of the fork – this gave rise to the affectionate nickname of “wonky signs”, because apparently this design gave the impression of a 3D look. Naturally it didn’t last as it was both space-consuming and, ultimately pointless given existing map type signs didn’t do it.

Pton1m

The 1 mile sign. Picture credit: AP.

1/2 mile advance direction sign

Unusually, this sign provided the ahead destinations instead of the final advance direction sign. This copied German practice which still applies to this day.  The pronounced ‘wonkiness’ is most evident on these signs. Another interesting design is how the fraction is shown, with a horizontal vinculum rather than the 1957 diagonal. The Anderson Committee reverted to the diagonal when reporting.

Signs on the New Preston By-Pass Motorway - 1958

The southbound 1/2 mile sign. Picture credit: Getty Images

Final advance direction sign

Unlike the previous sign, the final advance direction sign simply referenced the exit destinations.

28214807545_2d5c9fbd33_k

The southbound final sign (see above for the corresponding northbound one). Picture credit: Claude Ball, Flickr.

Diverge sign

The diverge sign differed from contemporary practice by again emulating German styles, in that there were no chevrons or arrows within the sign and the shape of it itself was deemed sufficient. The Anderson Committee favoured just using the route number with a hooked arrow, rather than a flag type sign. This practice was not always followed, however, in Lancashire at least, where flag type signs with the Anderson triangles were used.

27599761823_9bdbb1a345_k.jpg

27599761673_b849bbcb2a_k.jpg

The northbound and southbound diverge sign. Picture credit: Claude Ball, Flickr.

Leaving the motorway

Oddly, the decision was taken to use white backgrounds at the terminal points, along with the off-slips at the Tickled Trout interchange. Again, the Anderson Committee scrapped this in favour of all blue signs – coloured panels would not be used until 1994.

28214807265_be28f731da_k28137378151_8b9e2660f5_h

The signs on the mainline appeared to use experimental reflective areas. Also note the total absence of a border for the slip road direction signs. Picture credit: Claude Ball, Flickr.

Other oddities

The Preston Bypass used weird triangular countdown markers, which were explained helpfully by The Times before the motorway opened (see below).

Another oddity was the fact the Transport typeface had a flat-top 3, which was not reproduced in the Anderson Committee reports. In fact, if you look closely the image below, you can make out that the slope on the letter ‘t’ is much more pronounced as well, with other features like the tail of the letter ‘a’ being a little more flourished too. It’s evident this was most likely a hand-drawn experimental version of the typeface as it only had a single weight (what we’d now call ‘medium’, even on white backgrounds). The route number was not used on confirmation signs, instead this was a separate sign on the central reservation.

28181104726_9e694781d0_h

Preston_By-Pass_signs_-_Coppermine_-_3779.JPG

Picture credit: Claude Ball, Flickr, and SABRE.

And finally, the end of motorway ahead signs themselves were interesting. These were a giant red disc, again with 12-inch x-heights. These were replaced by rectangular blue signs in the final Anderson Report.

28181105686_a3c973c839_h.jpg

Approaching the end of motorway at the Bamber Bridge end. Picture credit: Claude Ball, Flickr.

Other than the photographic evidence we have, not much is archived from the early Preston experiments, as most material focuses on the actual road itself – thus proving once again that in highways engineering, traffic signs are the poor relation.

For a detailed history on the wider issues faced by the construction of the Preston Bypass, head on over to Chris Marshall’s brilliant website.

Stay tuned for the next part, covering the evolution of motorway signs from 1959 to 1964…

3 thoughts on “The Evolution of Motorway Signs – Part One

  1. Great article, Bryn, and you’ve managed to source lots of excellent photos of Anderson signs that I hadn’t seen before. Many of them are mounted on untidy scaffolding, implying that they were just temporary or experimental.

    The evolution of the motorway symbol could merit an article of its own. The Anderson Report of 1962 shows an inverted and slightly bolder version of the circular symbol in your photos, described as “Motorway symbol now suggested for use in this country”. Possibly this never appeared on actual signs, as the modern ‘chopsticks’ is illustrated on the opposite page as “Proposed modification of motorway symbol adopted by … ECE”. Paragraph 46 of the discussion leaves the question open for the Minister to decide, including the giving him the option of relying entirely on the blue colour scheme with no symbol at all.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s